Quincy University Hawks

2026 (Junior): Argetsinger appeared in one game during his first season with the Hawks, making his Quincy debut in a 27-4 win over Roosevelt (2/20/26). He went 0-for-1 with a walk and a run scored in the victory.
-    GLVC Academic All-Conference

2025 (Sophomore at Southwestern Illinois College): Argetsinger appeared in 47 games during his sophomore season at Southwestern Illinois College, batting .294 with a .386 on-base percentage and a .385 slugging percentage. He recorded five doubles, one triple, one home run, and 19 RBIs while continuing to be a steady presence in the lineup. He finished the season with six multi-hit games, including two three-hit performances.

2024 (Freshman at Southwestern Illinois College): Argetsinger put together a strong freshman season at Southwestern Illinois College, appearing in 39 games and posting a .360 batting average, .521 on-base percentage, and .551 slugging percentage across 89 at-bats. He recorded six doubles, one triple, three home runs, 29 RBIs, and showed strong plate discipline with 26 walks against just 16 strikeouts.

Argetsinger made his collegiate debut against Volunteer State (2/11/24) and recorded his first career hit in a win over Danville Area (2/18/24). He later hit his first collegiate home run in a victory over Three Rivers (3/19/24), which also served as his first career three-hit game. He finished the season with eight multi-hit performances.