Quincy University Hawks

2025 (Sophomore at Southwestern Illinois College): Argetsinger appeared in 47 games during his second season, batting .294 with five doubles, one triple, and one home run while driving in 19 runs. He recorded multiple multi-hit performances on the year.

2024 (Freshman at Southwestern Illinois College): As a freshman, Argetsinger appeared in 39 games and totaled 89 at-bats, posting a .360/.521/.551 slash line. He recorded six doubles, one triple, and three home runs while driving in 29 runs, drawing 26 walks against just 16 strikeouts. He made his collegiate debut against Volunteer State (2/11/24) and recorded his first career hit in an 11–2 win over Danville Area (2/18/24). Argetsinger hit his first career home run in a 17–1 victory over Three Rivers (3/19/24), which also marked his first career multi-hit game.